America, Iraq and the Legacy of Ahmad Chalabi | FRONTLINE | PBS


My first assembly with Ahmad Chalabi was 16 years in the past. I used to be engaged on a narrative about what was then a little bit identified group — Al Qaeda — and the August 1998 bombings of two U.S. embassies in East Africa. A colleague advised that Chalabi had one thing to say in regards to the plot. Again then, he was spending most of his time in Washington making the rounds between Capitol Hill, the Pentagon, the CIA, the State Division and the White Home. He was making an attempt to persuade anybody who would pay attention that Saddam Hussein was a grave risk to america and that America wanted to do every thing it may do to topple his regime.

I arrange a dinner assembly. By the point Chalabi arrived, two hours late, he informed me he had already eaten someplace else.

I ordered my meal and listened whereas he talked. “The African embassy bombings had been the work of Saddam,” he stated confidently. I bear in mind considering this was a fairly far-out declare. By then, I used to be fairly immersed within the story and nobody among the many authorities investigators I had spoken to had advised that the bombings had been linked to the Iraqi dictator in any manner.

However Chalabi, a political exile from Iraq, insisted. It needed to be Hussein, he defined, as a result of nobody else may have moved the required explosives and organized for the delicate, simultaneous bombings that killed greater than 200 individuals. I pressed him for proof and leads, however he was evasive and obscure. Trying again now, this was classic Chalabi — aloof and supremely self-confident. I left the assembly with nothing to go on.

After that, Chalabi fell off my radar for the following few years, however he stayed busy, urgent his case to top-level U.S. officers on the Pentagon, CIA and the vp’s workplace at each alternative. After 9/11, his efforts intensified. He informed anybody who would pay attention that his proof was stable.

The story is now well-known: Ahmed Chalabi was instrumental in convincing the U.S. authorities to ship troops into Iraq. For Chalabi, who died Tuesday on the age of 71, this can be his lasting legacy. Maybe the Bush administration would have discovered different causes had he not obliged, however because it was, Chalabi was the administration’s favourite Iraqi. Within the march to struggle, it was Chalabi that offered the administration with the important thing rationale it sought to justify the invasion — even when the intelligence was deeply flawed.

I noticed Chalabi for a second time in 2003 on the heels of the U.S. invasion. I met him on the Baghdad Searching Membership, the place he was organising the brand new headquarters of his Iraqi Nationwide Congress occasion. The place was swarming with journalists, spies and returning Iraqi ex-pats. The Iraqis reminisced about how they hadn’t seen the place since they had been children coming for dance classes and birthday events. The journalists, in the meantime, lined up for probabilities to speak to the person himself, Chalabi.

I took my flip and interviewed him on a veranda as different reporters regarded on. Chalabi was gloating, reveling within the glory of a returning hero. The dialog didn’t reveal a lot, apart from his delight at what he had helped accomplish — the overthrow of Hussein.

After I returned a pair months later, no weapons of mass destruction had been discovered and the early euphoria across the invasion had devolved into looting and demise. I interviewed Chalabi over two days in late July 2003 for my FRONTLINE documentary, Reality, Conflict & Penalties, and confronted him on the proof he offered to the Bush administration and to editors and reporters, together with some at The New York Occasions and FRONTLINE. Most memorable was his blithe dismissal of any concern that he may need misrepresented something. “We’re in Baghdad now,” is what he informed me.

Later within the interview, I requested Chalabi about his rivalry that Hussein and Al Qaeda had been related. He claimed to have a doc displaying cash altering fingers between Hussein’s authorities and Al Qaeda, however after repeated requests, I used to be by no means proven such a doc.

I traveled to Iraq many extra occasions over the following 10 years, however I didn’t trouble wanting Chalabi up once more till final yr.

I used to be in Iraq to cowl the rise of ISIS, and on the time, there have been frequent automotive bomb assaults as ISIS was doing its greatest to terrorize the capital after seizing a lot of Iraq’s north. A whole lot of time had handed and I believed maybe I may be taught extra from Chalabi — maybe time and all of the intervening bloodshed would have sobered the person. Actually issues didn’t prove as he had hoped. He by no means turned the nation’s prime minister, the job he lengthy sought. I referred to as him up and he agreed to obtain me on his father’s date farm on the outskirts of Baghdad.

I believed the assembly is likely to be quick, however then he sat for greater than 90 minutes into the late afternoon and patiently answered questions. Whereas we had been served espresso and fancy sweets, we talked about many issues. He appeared to benefit from the alternative. I recall considering he appeared lonely and that he appreciated the prospect to reminisce and maintain forth.

By this level, he was crucial of the U.S., and of the prime minister at the moment, Nouri al Maliki. Chalabi, a Shiite, was additionally weary of Saudi Arabian meddling in Iraq via its assist for Sunni militants.

It was extensively reported that Chalabi was making an attempt one other run on the prime minister spot, and I requested him about it. He denied any such factor. I then turned again to 2003, and requested if he had any regrets in regards to the “proof” he had offered, and in regards to the function he performed in purging the federal government of 1000’s of Baathists loyal to the Hussein regime — purges that led to a bitter divides, civil struggle and ultimately, the emergence of ISIS. The gist of what he informed me was that the American authorities misinterpreted what he informed them about weapons of mass destruction, and that he had vigorously opposed de-Baathification.

Listening, I spotted that this was the identical man I had met in 1998 and 2003 — somebody so assured that he had proper solutions for any query. But when he ever had regrets about his function within the invasion, and the years of violence it unleashed, he by no means voiced them to me.

Earlier than leaving I requested him if he thought ISIS posed a critical risk to Iraq. They had been holding about one third of the nation, together with the second largest metropolis in Iraq, Mosul. He denied there was a risk. Round that point an enormous explosion shook the whole room, rattling the doorways and home windows. He hardly flinched, and with a wave of his hand, dismissed the bomb as if a fly had landed on his arm.

Martin Smith is an Emmy- and Peabody-award-winning documentary filmmaker for FRONTLINE. For the reason that 2003 invasion of Iraq, Smith has coated the battle for FRONTLINE with a collection of movies, together with Reality, Conflict and Penalties (2003), Past Baghdad (2004), Non-public Warriors (2005), Gangs of Iraq (2007) and The Rise of ISIS (2014). Smith works with RAINmedia, an impartial manufacturing firm in New York Metropolis.


Martin Smith



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *