Utah journalists can no longer interview lawmakers on Senate and House floors without permission


Credentialed reporters are actually restricted from coming into the Home and Senate flooring of the Utah Capitol to conduct interviews with out permission.

(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) The Utah Capitol at nightfall on Wednesday, Feb. 5, 2020, throughout the legislative session.

The Utah Home of Representatives restricted media entry to lawmakers on the statehouse flooring on Tuesday.

After a virtually 20-minute debate, state representatives moved to approve the Home guidelines decision sponsored by Rep. James Dunnigan, R-Taylorsville, on a 65 to 9 vote.

Credentialed reporters are actually restricted from coming into the Home and Senate flooring of the Capitol with out permission, a transfer that has sparked criticism from media shops and press advocacy organizations.

Dunnigan’s guidelines decision that alters media entry within the Home chamber mirrors an analogous measure permitted by the Senate final month. HR2 prevents credentialed journalists from coming into nonpublic areas of the Home, together with the chamber, halls and convention rooms, to conduct and document interviews with out the permission of the Home speaker or speaker’s designee. The principles change additionally requires reporters to acquire approval from a committee chair earlier than standing behind a committee room dais.

A couple of lawmakers, each Republican and Democrat, overtly opposed the principles decision limiting entry to media.

Throughout flooring debate of the principles decision, state Rep. Suzanne Harrison, D-Draper, requested Dunnigan if there had been any situations the place reporters harassed lawmakers or revealed personal info when wanting over their shoulder.

Dunnigan mentioned typically lawmakers really feel uncomfortable their computer systems or telephones when a videographer is standing behind a lawmaker throughout a committee assembly. Photographers and videographers usually stand behind the dais throughout a committee assembly to seize footage of a lawmaker or witness testifying for or in opposition to a invoice.

“So far as the nonpublic areas, I’ll simply state once more, these are nonpublic areas. I feel the media ought to have entry, and I feel the speaker or his designee will give them entry. All they should do is request it for these nonpublic areas,” Dunnigan mentioned.

“I simply have considerations concerning the restrictions on our free press,” Harrison mentioned in response. “I really feel like if there’s abusive practices or harassment happening in any method, I feel that would definitely warrant … a person being restricted, however I feel our free press performs an important position in holding energy to account and the enterprise of the general public must be performed in public, and for that motive, I’ll be voting no.”

State Rep. Norm Thurston, R-Provo, mentioned he supported regulating media entry to the Home flooring and mentioned it might cease reporters’ “gotcha strategy” when requesting interviews with lawmakers.

“I’ve seen many examples of media, ready till the tip of flooring time and coming onto the Home flooring whilst you’re at your desk and … leaning up in your desk and saying, ‘Can I ask you a query?’ with a with a tape recorder in your face,” Thurston mentioned. “If a media individual needs to speak to you, they might have the decency to name your cellphone and schedule a time to inform you what they need to discuss, which is per their code of ethics, so that you’ve time to organize what it’s that you simply’re going to speak about.”

In prior periods, journalists have historically requested interviews with lawmakers throughout recess contained in the statehouse chamber to succeed in a lawmaker earlier than they left for one more assembly or committee room.

Minority Chief Brian King, D-Salt Lake Metropolis, mentioned he was involved the principles decision would restrict transparency.

“I need to guarantee that our media once they’re appearing — particularly as they nearly at all times do in my notion — with integrity and honesty, are in a position to assist us do our jobs effectively,” he mentioned. “We are able to’t successfully act as legislators within the state of Utah with out the issues that we’re doing right here being reported to the individuals of the state of Utah, truthfully and with integrity. And after I requested myself if this rule change on these explicit strains strikes us in that path, I simply don’t really feel that we’re moving into the suitable path on that.”

State Rep. Steve Useful, R-Layton, who used to work within the newspaper advertising enterprise, additionally opposed the principles decision.

“I feel their job is crucial to what we’re doing right here within the legislature. There have to be sunshine, as a lot as we can provide,” he mentioned. “I do know that we’re simply making an attempt to regulate the principles and put this in writing, however I feel the optics are horrible. I actually suppose they’re horrible.”

Dunnigan famous that credentialed reporters nonetheless have a delegated media house within the Home chamber, which is situated within the gallery on the second flooring.

“We’re not making an attempt to restrict the media. They’re a helpful associate. We’d like them. We admire them and we would like them to have continued entry. However these are the nonpublic areas. They only should get permission from the speaker or the designee,” he mentioned.

This yr, different Republican-controlled statehouses in Iowa and Kansas have additionally taken steps to restrict media entry to lawmakers.

Lawmakers revise bill so journalists will be allowed in public spaces


Media, which can nonetheless be restricted on home flooring, advocated for creation of a Capitol Press Corps at Utah statehouse.

On this March 2, 2015 photograph, Home of Representatives Majority Chief James A. Dunnigan R-Taylorsville, proper, huddles with then-Majority Assistant Whip, Brad R. Wilson R-Kaysville in Salt Lake Metropolis.

The Home Guidelines Committee on Monday unanimously voted in favor of a guidelines change that may restrict media entry to lawmakers on the Home of Representatives flooring.

HR2 would require credentialed journalists to hunt approval of the Home of Representatives speaker or speaker’s designee earlier than getting into the Home flooring to interview a lawmaker.

The invoice, sponsored by state Rep. James Dunnigan, R-Taylorsville, initially sought to require journalists to get the permission of the Home of Representatives speaker to enter Home committee rooms, that are public areas. The substitute invoice filed on Sunday evening and introduced to lawmakers on Monday morning strikes that measure.

“I attempted to collect some enter from the media on this decision and the decision is modified primarily based on that medium, a number of the enter and a number of the data they supplied and issues they identified,” Dunnigan mentioned.

The measure is sort of an identical to a guidelines decision accepted by Utah Senate Republicans this month. State Sen. Mike McKell, R-Spanish Fork, who sponsored that laws, beforehand mentioned the measure would set up clear guidelines over media entry.

Below the home decision, journalists would nonetheless want the permission of a committee chair to face behind the committee room dais throughout a gathering. Photographers and videographers usually stand behind the rostrum in committee rooms to seize footage of a lawmaker or witness testifying for or towards a invoice.

“The permission might be verbal, it could possibly be digital, it could possibly be thumbs-up,” Dunnigan mentioned. “They simply must have the chairman’s permission so the chairman can nonetheless handle the committee.”

Renae Cowley a consultant of the Utah Medial Coalition, advisable the creation of a Capitol Press Corps group that may symbolize the Capitol Preservation Board, legislative leaders from the Home and Senate and reporters.

“We would love to work together with your physique on making a Utah press corps,” Cowley mentioned. “It does supply the media and members of the press the chance to be part of a number of the selections made relating to their observe and their occupation.”

Dunnigan mentioned he favored the concept of building a Capitol Press Corps group.

“I really like the idea of getting some from Home and Senate, the media, the Capitol Preservation Board and having dialogue on this,” he mentioned.

Ben Winslow, a FOX13 reporter, mentioned he had “sensible issues” about asking a committee chair if a videographer or photographer may arrange their tools in the midst of a committee assembly.

“Do I stand within the again and leap up and down and lift my palms to attempt to get consideration?” he mentioned. ” Clearly, the purpose of stories media entry to the committee room or the Home flooring is to behave because the eyes and ears for the general public, exhibiting folks every day what their elected officers are doing.”

Winslow additionally advocated for establishing a Capitol Press Corps group to deal with the press credentialing course of on the state Capitol and different points that come up.

Dunnigan’s guidelines decision now heads to the Home and requires two-thirds approval in that chamber to move.

Lawmakers revise bill so journalists will be allowed in public spaces


The Home Guidelines Committee on Monday unanimously voted in favor of a guidelines change that may restrict media entry to lawmakers on the Home of Representatives ground.

HR2 would require credentialed journalists to hunt approval of the Home of Representatives speaker or speaker’s designee earlier than getting into the Home ground to interview a lawmaker.

The invoice, sponsored by state Rep. James Dunnigan, R-Taylorsville, initially sought to require journalists to get the permission of the Home of Representatives speaker to enter Home committee rooms, that are public areas. The substitute invoice filed on Sunday evening and introduced to lawmakers on Monday morning strikes that measure.

“I attempted to collect some enter from the media on this decision and the decision is modified based mostly on that medium, a few of the enter and a few of the info they supplied and issues they identified,” Dunnigan mentioned.

The measure is almost similar to a guidelines decision accepted by Utah Senate Republicans this month. State Sen. Mike McKell, R-Spanish Fork, who sponsored that laws, beforehand mentioned the measure would set up clear guidelines over media entry.

Below the home decision, journalists would nonetheless want the permission of a committee chair to face behind the committee room dais throughout a gathering. Photographers and videographers usually stand behind the rostrum in committee rooms to seize footage of a lawmaker or witness testifying for or towards a invoice.

“The permission may be verbal, it may very well be digital, it may very well be thumbs-up,” Dunnigan mentioned. “They simply must have the chairman’s permission so the chairman can nonetheless handle the committee.”

Renae Cowley a consultant of the Utah Medial Coalition, beneficial the creation of a Capitol Press Corps group that may signify the Capitol Preservation Board, legislative leaders from the Home and Senate and reporters.

“We would love to work together with your physique on making a Utah press corps,” Cowley mentioned. “It does supply the media and members of the press the chance to be part of a few of the choices made concerning their apply and their occupation.”

Dunnigan mentioned he favored the thought of creating a Capitol Press Corps group.

“I like the idea of getting some from Home and Senate, the media, the Capitol Preservation Board and having dialogue on this,” he mentioned.

Ben Winslow, a FOX13 reporter, mentioned he had “sensible issues” about asking a committee chair if a videographer or photographer might arrange their gear in the midst of a committee assembly.

“Do I stand within the again and bounce up and down and lift my palms to attempt to get consideration?” he mentioned. ” Clearly, the purpose of stories media entry to the committee room or the Home ground is to behave because the eyes and ears for the general public, exhibiting individuals every day what their elected officers are doing.”

Winslow additionally advocated for establishing a Capitol Press Corps group to deal with the press credentialing course of on the state Capitol and different points that come up.

Dunnigan’s guidelines decision now heads to the Home and requires two-thirds approval in that chamber to cross.